Blog - Dakota Storage

Prefab Sheds vs. Custom Sheds: Which Is Best for You?

Written by Dakota Storage Buildings | May 09, 2025

You don’t have to choose between quality and price.

If you’re in the market for a shed, you naturally want to find one that meets your needs, is a value for the price, and fits your budget. A common first step is asking, "How much does a shed cost?" Many buyers start by looking at prefab sheds (also referred to as stock sheds) because they believe they are less expensive than custom sheds.

But those gorgeous custom sheds keep calling to you, don’t they?

So, which IS best for you? That’s your call, of course. But making that decision doesn’t have to be overwhelming.

That’s why we’ve put together this detailed guide, complete with visuals and real buyer insights to help you confidently choose the right shed. We’ll break down cost, durability, customization, and delivery time, so you can easily see which option aligns with your needs.

By the time you’re done reading, you’ll know exactly which shed option is best for your space, budget, and long-term plans. Let’s dive in!

Prefab Sheds: A Budget-Friendly Storage Solution

If you're looking for a larger-sized shed, prefab options may have some size limitations compared to fully custom-built structures. However, there are high-quality prefab sheds available with durable materials and solid construction. Some models feature treated wood flooring and reinforced joists for longevity, while others may use different materials that vary in durability.

To ensure you're getting a shed that meets your long-term needs, it's always a good idea to compare materials, check flooring and structural reinforcements, and ask about maintenance requirements before making a purchase. With the right choice, a high-quality prefab shed can provide reliable storage and functionality for years.

So, how much does a shed cost? One great thing about prefab sheds is that they are often less expensive than custom sheds. Prices for prefab sheds tend to average $1,500 to $4,000, with larger or more specialized farm sheds reaching $10,000 or more.

Most people who purchase prefab sheds tend to use them as storage or garden sheds, with popular sizes ranging from 10’x12’ to 10’x14’.

How Prefab Shed Delivery Works for You

For buyers who need fast storage solutions, prefab sheds are an excellent choice. They can be delivered as-is or quickly assembled on-site, often within hours, making them ideal for those who don’t want to wait weeks or months for construction. A well-made prefab shed with treated materials can last up to 20 years, providing long-term value with minimal hassle.

Here’s how the process works:

  1. Select Your Shed: Choose from a variety of in-stock prefab sheds in different sizes and styles that best suit your needs.
  2. Schedule Delivery: Once you’ve made your selection, set up a convenient delivery date. Many prefab sheds arrive fully assembled or in large pre-built sections for fast setup.
  3. On-Site Placement: The shed is transported and placed onto your prepared foundation, ensuring a smooth installation.
  4. Immediate Use: Most prefab sheds require little to no assembly, so you can start using your new storage space right away.

With a pre-built shed, you can skip the long wait times and enjoy a ready-to-go storage solution without dealing with construction delays.

Custom Sheds: The Ultimate Solution for Unique Storage Needs

The best part and greatest advantage of buying a custom shed is that it’s made to your unique specifications. It’s built just for you.

If you want a shingled roof with metal siding, it’s yours. If you want a drive-through shed, it’s yours. If you want to create a shed big enough for a loft sleeping area, it’s yours. If you want an L-shaped shed for an L-shaped space in your backyard, it’s yours.

You get our point. Creating a custom shed is the primary way to get the exact shed you want.

Here are more benefits of buying a custom shed:

  • When you hire a reputable custom shed builder, your shed will be built well: no shortcuts in construction.
  • If you want a shed to be placed at a specific spot on your property and if you’re willing to pay more for it, it can be built on-site, thus eliminating the chance the builder may not be able to deliver it to you due to public roads or your landscape’s constraints.

Personalize Every Detail of Your Shed

One of the biggest benefits of custom sheds is the ability to personalize every detail. Whether you need a home office, workshop, or extra-large storage space, you can tailor your shed to fit your exact needs.

Exterior Customization Options

  • Choose from wood, metal, or vinyl siding to match your home’s aesthetic.
  • Select roofing materials such as shingles or metal for durability and style.
  • Customize windows and doors, including single, double, or roll-up garage doors for easier access.

Interior Features and Layout

  • Add built-in shelving and lofts for extra storage.
  • Upgrade flooring with reinforced or moisture-resistant materials for heavy-duty use.
  • Install insulation and electrical wiring for a year-round workspace.
  • Design a custom layout to fit unique property constraints, such as L-shaped sheds, multi-room setups, or drive-through storage designs.

If you have a specific vision for your shed, a custom-built option allows you to bring it to life with features that maximize functionality and durability.

Semi-Custom Sheds: The Best of Both Worlds 

Another option to consider is a compromise between prefab sheds and custom sheds: semi-customizable sheds. This option gives you the best of both worlds — the affordability and fast turnaround of prefab sheds with the flexibility of customization.

At Dakota, we offer shed packages that allow you to choose a base model and then personalize key details like siding, color, and additional features. This approach is more budget-friendly than a fully custom-built shed, while still letting you tailor the look and functionality to your specific needs.

For instance, you could start with our Modern Backyard Shed package and then customize it to match your house color, add extra windows for natural light, or select features that blend seamlessly into your outdoor living space.

Design Your Perfect Shed in MinutesWith the 3D Configurator

Our 3D Configurator makes this process simple and stress-free. Instead of imagining how your shed will look, you can visualize every detail in real time before making a decision. 

This step-by-step customization process ensures that you get a high-quality, affordable shed that meets your storage needs — without the wait time or cost of a fully custom build.

Key Factors to Consider Before You Buy

Before making a decision, think about the following factors to determine whether a prefab or custom shed is the right fit:

Budget: Figure out how much does a shed cost, then ask yourself, how much are you willing to invest? Prefab sheds tend to be more budget-friendly, while custom sheds offer higher quality and long-term value.

Storage Needs: What will you be storing? If you need basic outdoor storage, a pre-built sheds may suffice. If you require workspace functionality or specialized storage, custom features might be necessary.

Timeline: How soon do you need your shed? Prefab sheds are available almost immediately, while custom sheds require more time for planning and construction.

Property Size & Restrictions: Does your yard have size limitations or HOA restrictions? A custom shed allows for flexibility in placement and design, whereas prefab sheds come in standard sizes.

Design Preferences: Do you want a shed that blends with your home? Custom sheds allow you to match colors, materials, and layout to your exact specifications.

By considering these factors, you’ll have a clearer idea of which shed option best suits your needs.

Which Shed is Right for You?

The best shed for you depends on your budget, storage needs, and timeline. If you need a quick, affordable storage solution, a prefab shed is an excellent choice. But if you’re looking for customization, premium quality, and a long-term investment, a custom-built shed is the way to go.

At Dakota, we’re committed to helping you find the best shed for your needs — not just selling you a structure. Whether you’re leaning toward a prefab model or a fully customized design, we’re here to guide you every step of the way.

Need help deciding? Download our Shed Buying Workbook and find the perfect storage solution today!