Shop Pre-built
Design Your Own

Shed Cost: Storage Shed vs Storage Unit — What’s Best?

by Dakota Storage Buildings, on April 11, 2024

Blog_Storage Unit vs Shed_900x450

In today’s fast-paced world, the challenge of managing our possessions to maximize space can often feel like a complex puzzle. Families often have to find a balance between keeping precious memorabilia and maintaining a clutter-free home. These items require careful preservation, yet their sheer volume can infringe upon living spaces, leading to environments that feel cramped. For entrepreneurs and small business owners, the dilemma often revolves around managing inventory or essential documents. The growth of a business is always a cause for celebration, but expansion can quickly outpace the confines of your current space. When your home is overflowing with items, you may need to consider a storage solution that is both secure and accessible, without committing to the significant financial cost of a larger, more permanent facility.

Investing in an outdoor storage building, with its promise of on-site, dedicated space, is a tempting solution but many have initial concerns, primarily the cost. The price of a high-quality shed can be substantial, leading many to second-guess this option despite its long-term benefits. However, the idea of digging through attic clutter or reorganizing existing spaces to make room for storage can be daunting. For a business, the hesitation to commit to larger premises is understandable. The financial implications and the permanence of the decision can make the flexibility of a non-permanent storage solution highly appealing. This is where the choice between renting a storage unit and investing in a storage shed becomes particularly relevant. Each option presents a viable solution to the pressing need for additional space, yet they offer contrasting benefits and limitations.

The decision between a storage unit and a storage shed is not only a matter of the shed cost but a reflection of a person’s lifestyle, business needs, and long-term planning. The convenience and immediacy of a rented unit compared to the value and utility of a personally owned shed. Understanding the nuances of each option will be crucial in making an informed choice that aligns with individual preferences and requirements. Let us take a closer look at each of these storage solutions, weighing their pros and cons to find the most fitting answer to your space-related challenges.

Storage Unit Pros and Cons

Blog_Storage Unit_900x450

Storage units, with their promise of secure, flexible storage options, can be an appealing alternative for those grappling with limited space at home or in their businesses. However, like any solution, opting for a storage unit has unique advantages and challenges. It is important to weigh these factors carefully to determine whether a storage unit aligns with your long-term storage needs and lifestyle preferences.


Easy Access: Storage units are designed to cater to a wide range of storage needs, offering easy access and a variety of sizes to accommodate everything from small personal items to large vehicles. Wide hallways and pathways ensure that moving items in and out is a hassle-free process. This accessibility is particularly beneficial for those who will need frequent access to their stored belongings.

Climate Control: Many storage units come with climate control options, providing an ideal environment for items that are sensitive to temperature fluctuations or humidity. This feature is crucial for preserving the integrity of valuable possessions such as artwork, musical instruments, and electronic devices, ensuring they remain in pristine condition over time.

Versatile Storage Options: The versatility of storage units is evident in the range of sizes available, from compact lockers to expansive spaces capable of storing RVs. This flexibility allows individuals to select a unit that perfectly matches their storage requirements, whether they are looking to store a few boxes or the contents of an entire house.

Convenient Payment Methods: Online payment options have streamlined the process of managing storage unit rentals. Customers can easily keep up with their payments from the convenience of their personal devices, eliminating the need for physical checks or in-person payments. This modern convenience enhances the overall user experience, making storage units an attractive option for those seeking simplicity and efficiency.


Distance from Home: One significant drawback of storage units is their location away from the user's residence. This distance necessitates travel every time an item needs to be retrieved or stored, which can be inconvenient and time-consuming, especially for items that are needed regularly.

Limited Access Hours: Storage facilities typically operate within set hours, which may not always align with renters' schedules. This limitation can restrict access to stored items during nights, weekends, or holidays, posing a challenge for those who require more flexible access to their belongings.

Ongoing Monthly Fees: The cost of renting a storage unit can accumulate quickly, with monthly fees adding up over time. Unlike investments in property that can appreciate and offer a return, these fees do not contribute to any form of ownership or equity, representing a continuous financial outlay with no tangible asset in return. There are better storage options that do not require a continuous investment in an inconvenient storage solution. 

Lack of Personalization: Storage units offer little to no opportunity for personalization or modification to better suit individual storage needs. Renters must adapt to the unit's existing dimensions and layout, which may not always provide the most efficient or convenient storage solution for every situation.

Storage Sheds Pros and Cons

Blog_Tan Storage Shed_900x450-1

Storage sheds are a popular solution, offering a blend of convenience, durability, and aesthetic appeal unmatched by other storage methods. However, the decision to invest in a storage shed involves careful consideration of both its advantages and the initial financial commitment required. It is essential to understand the full spectrum of what an outdoor storage building can offer and the considerations it entails.


Immediate Accessibility: The most prominent advantage of owning a storage shed is the unparalleled convenience it offers. Positioned just a few steps from your back door, a shed provides instant access to your belongings without the need for transportation. This ease of access is priceless for frequent use, allowing for seamless retrieval and storage of items as needed throughout the year.

Durability and Quality: Storage sheds are renowned for their construction from high-quality materials. This ensures not only a robust and durable storage solution but also one that withstands varying weather conditions, protecting your possessions over time. The assurance of receiving a product that does not compromise on quality is a significant benefit for shed owners.

Enhances Property Value: Investing in a storage shed is not just about gaining extra space; it is also about adding value to your property. A well-constructed shed not only addresses your immediate storage needs but also contributes to the overall appeal and functionality of your property, making it an attractive feature for potential future buyers.

Customization Options: The ability to customize a storage shed is a considerable advantage. Whether you need specific features like extra windows for natural light, specialized siding to match your house, or additional shelving for organization, sheds can be tailored to meet your exact requirements, making them a versatile addition to your property.


Upfront Cost: You may be wondering, how much does a shed cost? The primary downside to purchasing a storage shed is the initial investment required. The cost for building a shed directly reflects the craftsmanship and materials used. The upfront shed cost can be a significant consideration for those weighing the benefits of shed ownership against their current financial situation. However, some manufacturers offer financing options that would be similar to a monthly storage unit rental fee.

Delivery and Installation Requirements: The logistics of delivering and installing a shed on your property are additional considerations. Adequate space for the shed's placement and potentially necessary groundwork to ensure a stable foundation are crucial factors that can complicate and add to the overall cost of acquiring a shed.

The Cost-effective Benefits of Storage Sheds

When considering the financial factors of additional storage space, affordability can be an attractive option. A storage unit’s month-to-month payment structure allows for a seemingly low-commitment solution to immediate storage needs. However, this perceived convenience has a significant long-term financial consideration: the cumulative cost of these rentals over time can become a substantial financial burden. Plus, this ongoing expense does not result in any form of property ownership. Renters of storage units must reckon with the reality that, despite years of payments, they will not gain equity or tangible assets; the funds expended on storage unit rentals do not offer any return on investment or contribute to the renter's net worth.

Choosing to purchase an outdoor storage building can be a more substantial initial financial commitment, often requiring either an upfront payment or a financing plan. The cost of building a shed may seem high, but opting for financing introduces a temporary phase of monthly payments, similar to those of a rental unit but with a crucial difference. These payments are finite, leading towards outright ownership of the shed. When the payment plan is completed, the shed becomes a lasting asset, enhancing the value and utility of the property. This transition from a temporary expense to a permanent property improvement marks a significant advantage of shed ownership over renting storage space. The shed not only serves the immediate practical purpose of solving storage challenges but also contributes to the overall value of the property, potentially increasing its market appeal and resale value.

Owning a storage shed also eliminates the recurring financial obligations associated with storage unit rentals. Once the shed is fully paid for, the owner enjoys the benefits of additional storage space without ongoing costs, breaking the cycle of perpetual payments demanded by rental units. This shift to a one-time investment with lasting benefits emphasizes the financial benefits of choosing a storage shed. In the long run, the shed's cost will be paid off, providing storage solutions and property enhancement without the continuous drain on financial resources. This makes the shed not only a wise choice for immediate storage needs but also a sound investment in one's property and financial future.

Storage Solutions that Last

Blog_Modern Backyard Shed_900x450

Choosing between a storage shed and a storage unit boils down to long-term value versus short-term convenience. While both have their place, a storage shed stands out as the more sensible investment over time. Not only does it offer immediate, on-site access to your belongings, but it also enhances the value of your property and eventually frees you from ongoing costs. Before making your decision, consider the long-term benefits and potential return on investment a shed offers. If you are leaning towards a shed but are concerned about the shed cost, remember that many companies, including Dakota Storage Buildings, offer financing options to make the purchase more manageable.

A storage shed is not just about creating extra space; it is about investing in your property and lifestyle. With a shed, you are creating a more organized, efficient, and clutter-free environment. So, before you sign another rental agreement for a storage unit, think about the lasting benefits a shed can bring to your life. Ready to explore your options further? Dive into our Shed Buying Workbook to help guide you through the process of selecting the perfect storage solution for your needs. Whether it is decluttering your home or finding a secure place for your business inventory, a storage shed offers a versatile, cost-effective solution that stands the test of time.

Download Our Shed Buying Workbook

Topics:ShedsShed Ideas & Organization Tips

Subscribe to Updates


What goes into finding your best-fit shed?